Showing posts with label Academic Publishing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Academic Publishing. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 1, 2026

From Andragogy to Artificial Intelligence: Tracing the Evolution of Adult Education Through Scholarly Journals Published by AAACE

 


 

By Lilian H. Hill (HOF 2018)

 

In adult and continuing education, scholarly journals provide a unique lens through which to examine how ideas develop over time, revealing not only what educators and researchers have studied, but also whose voices have been amplified, whose perspectives have been overlooked, and how the field has responded to changing social realities. A review of publications in adult and continuing education journals demonstrates that the field has undergone significant intellectual transformation over the past several decades.

 

Looking Beyond Familiar Names

Introductory adult education texts in the U.S. foreground a relatively small group of influential scholars, including Eduard Lindeman, Malcolm Knowles, David Kolb, Jack Mezirow, Sharan Merriam, and Stephen Brookfield. While these individuals made foundational contributions to the field, relying on a handful of familiar citations creates an impression that adult education scholarship is static. Instead, adult education is a rich and evolving field shaped by hundreds of scholars, practitioners, and community leaders across the globe.

 

An illustration of this diversity is the International Adult and Continuing Education Hall of Fame, which over the past thirty years has recognized nearly 500 leaders from over 40 countries for their contributions to adult and continuing education. The Hall of Fame includes researchers, practitioners, policy leaders, and innovators whose work spans community development, literacy, workforce education, transformative learning, lifelong learning, higher education, and social justice. The work of the Hall of Fame is ongoing with a new inductees honored each year.

 

Hall of Fame members have contributed directly to the scholarly literature. Foundational scholars include Malcolm Knowles (1996), Phyllis Cunningham (1996), Jack Mezirow (2003), Sharan Merriam (2003), Thomas Sork (2008), Stephen Brookfield (2009), John Dirkx (2013), and Patricia Cranton (2014). They published influential work, helping shape major areas of inquiry including andragogy, transformative learning, critical reflection, adult development, and lifelong learning. The date in brackets that follows scholars’ names represents the year they were inducted. Induction tends to occur when scholars are well-established, and sometimes years later. For example, Eduard Lindeman was inducted posthumously in 2002, yet his well-known publication, The Meaning of Adult Education, was released in 1926.

 

Journals as Windows into the Field

Journals demonstrate how knowledge production changes over time. Academic journals reveal the questions that scholars considered important, theoretical frameworks that gained prominence, and social issues that influenced research. They reflect shifting priorities, emerging debates, and growing recognition of previously marginalized voices. By examining publication trends, it becomes possible to trace the evolution of adult education as both a scholarly discipline and a social practice. This blog post focuses on publications of the American Association of Adult and Continuing Education (AAACE): Adult Education Quarterly, Adult Learning, and Journal of Transformative Education.

 

 

Mid-Twentieth Century: Education for Democracy and Community Development

During the 1950s - 1970s, adult education scholars focused heavily on program development, community education, civic participation, and democratic engagement. Adult education was viewed as a practical endeavor that could strengthen communities and support social progress. Research emphasized effective teaching strategies for adult learners. Theories such as andragogy, experiential learning, and humanistic education gained prominence, reflecting a strong interest in understanding how adults learn and how educators could facilitate that learning more effectively. Broader social movements, including civil rights activism, labor organizing, and community development efforts, influenced the field. Adult education was closely connected to social purpose, citizenship, and collective improvement.

 

The 1980s and 1990s: Critical Reflection and Theory Development

The 1980s and 1990s marked a significant shift in adult education scholarship. Rather than focusing primarily on instructional methods, scholars began exploring deeper questions about power, inequality, and social structures. This era saw the emergence and expansion of transformative learning theory alongside growing influence from critical theory, feminist scholarship, and critical pedagogy. Researchers began asking important questions about who participates in adult education, who benefits whose knowledge is considered legitimate, and how learning experiences shape identity and power? The field moved beyond questions of how adults learn to examine why education matters and whom it serves. Adult education became increasingly concerned with issues of justice, equity, and social transformation.

 

The Adult and Continuing Education Hall of Fame inducted its first 78 scholars in 1996. The Hall had been in development for several years, and the induction recognized adult educators who were active in previous decades. Scholars who contributed to the literature who were inducted that year included Phyllis Cunningham, Cyril Houle, Alan Knox, and K. Patricia Cross. Authors inducted in the remainder of the decade include Peter Jarvis (1997), Myles Horton (1998), Donna Queeny (1998), and Dorothy Enderis (1998).

 

The Early 2000s: Globalization and Lifelong Learning

As globalization accelerated, adult education became increasingly international and interdisciplinary. Researchers explored cross-cultural perspectives and examined how global economic, political, and social changes influenced learning. Governments, international organizations, and educational institutions increasingly promoted lifelong learning as essential for workforce development, economic competitiveness, and adaptation to rapid social change.

 

At the same time, scholars debated competing visions of education. Was adult education primarily an economic tool designed to increase productivity and employability? Or was it a means of promoting social justice, civic engagement, and personal growth? This tension between economic and social purposes remains a defining feature of contemporary adult education discourse. Hall of Fame members who contributed to that debate included Ronald Cervero (2003), Stephen Brookfield (2009), Patricia Cranton (2014), John Dirkx (2018), and Laura Bierema (2022).

 

The 2010s: Equity, Identity, and Technology

During the 2010s, adult education scholarship increasingly focused on issues of equity, inclusion, identity, and culture. Researchers examined how race, gender, social class, disability, and other dimensions of identity influence educational experiences and outcomes. The field responded to major global challenges, including migration, economic instability, and public health crises. Greater attention was given to amplifying marginalized voices and understanding how systemic inequalities shape access to learning opportunities. Technology emerged as another major area of inquiry. Scholars investigated online learning, digital access, and the ways technology influences participation, engagement, and educational outcomes. Research increasingly blended theoretical analysis with practical applications, reflecting the growing need to address real-world challenges facing educators and learners. Hall of Fame Members active during this time included Stephen Brookfield (2009), Juanita Johnson-Bailey (2009), Elizabeth Tisdell (2014), John Dirkx (2018), Simone Conceição (2018), Paulette Isaac-Savage (2019), and Edward Taylor (2024).

 

The 2020s and Beyond: Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Challenges

The current decade is generating new questions for adult education scholars. Digital, media, and artificial intelligence literacy, and the ethical implications of emerging technologies have become prominent topics of discussion. Adult educators are learning to teach adults about addressing misinformation and disinformation, digital inequity, workforce disruption, and the changing nature of knowledge production. At the same time, foundational literacy skills remain important concerns. Ongoing focus on social justice, global interconnectedness, and lifelong learning continue to shape research and practice. Hall of Fame authors publishing in this decade include Chad Hoggan (2025), Lisa Baumgartner (2024), Lisa Merriweather (2024), and Laura Bierema (2022). There are more adult educators still to be recognized in this decade. Future scholarship will likely explore how artificial intelligence, data-driven systems, and evolving digital environments influence learning, teaching, and participation in society.

 

Lessons from the Evolution of Adult Education

Adult education has evolved from a largely practice-oriented field to one that is theoretically sophisticated, critically reflective, globally connected, and increasingly interdisciplinary. Throughout its history, the field has maintained an ongoing dialogue with society. Changes in scholarship have often mirrored broader social, political, economic, and technological developments. New ideas have emerged in response to changing contexts, while longstanding debates about purpose, access, equity, and power continue to resurface in new forms. The challenge for contemporary scholars is to engage with the broader and continually expanding body of literature that reflects the diversity, complexity, and global nature of adult learning and education.

 

Understanding this intellectual evolution helps educators and researchers situate their own work within a larger scholarly tradition. It highlights the diversity of voices that have contributed to the field and encourages engagement with both foundational theories and contemporary scholarship. Most importantly, the history of adult education reminds us that the field is not defined by a handful of influential thinkers. Rather, it is a living, evolving conversation shaped by generations of scholars, practitioners, and learners working to understand and improve the role of education in adult life.

 

Wednesday, July 30, 2025

Building Bridges Through Scholarship – Cooperation Among Journals in Adult and Continuing Education


 

The landscape of academic publishing in adult and continuing education has grown significantly over the past few decades. While the field once had only a few specialized journals, today there is a wide array of scholarly platforms exploring lifelong learning, adult basic education, non-formal learning, workforce development, and more. Despite this expansion, fragmentation persists, and opportunities for collective advancement remain underutilized.

 

At the 2024 Hall of Fame Induction Conference in Florence, Working Group 7 (WG7) on Journals Cooperation, mentored by Paolo Federighi (IACEHOF 2019), brought together editors, researchers, and educators to consider collaborating more effectively. Their goal: to enhance the visibility, accessibility, and impact of adult education scholarship through coordinated strategies and shared infrastructure.

 

A Changing Landscape in Academic Publishing

As the number of journals has increased, so has the diversity of publishers. Today, journals are hosted by public institutions, non-governmental organizations, research centers, and commercial publishers. Universities fund some, others operate independently, and a few have achieved financial autonomy. Despite their different origins, all share common goals: high-quality scholarship, broad readership, and real-world relevance.

 

To meet these goals, WG7 members emphasized the need for collective efforts that preserve scholarly integrity while supporting innovation, access, and global engagement.

 

The Case for Journal Cooperation

The group recognized that academic journals—particularly those in adult and continuing education—often compete for submissions, citations, and readership. However, cooperation, or “co-petition,” could allow journals to maintain healthy competition while advancing shared objectives.

Benefits of cooperation could include:

  • Reducing duplication of effort across editorial boards
  • Supporting early-career and emerging scholars
  • Increasing global visibility and citation impact
  • Encouraging multilingual and multicultural scholarship
  • Amplifying the voice of adult education in public discourse

 

Proposed Actions and Collaborative Mechanisms

To operationalize this vision, the working group proposed several concrete initiatives:

1.    A Shared Online Platform: A centralized webpage would present all participating journals, their calls for papers, and links to their websites. This platform would be a one-stop resource for authors, reviewers, and readers. The University of Florence offered to host this initiative under the Hall of Fame for Adult and Continuing Education (HOFE) umbrella.

2.    Establishing Minimum Quality Standards: Journals must meet basic legitimacy and scholarly rigor standards to be included on the shared platform. This would help distinguish “legitimate” journals from “predatory” ones. The standards could include peer review practices, editorial board transparency, indexing status, and ethical publishing policies.

3.    Inclusivity in Language and Geography: The platform would feature journals from all parts of the world and in all languages, reflecting the global nature of adult education. Emphasis would be placed on increasing the visibility of journals currently “invisible” in mainstream academic circles due to language or limited distribution.

4.    Supporting Emerging Scholars: The platform could highlight journals that publish early-career researchers and provide mentorship during peer review. Special issues could focus on topics of interest to new scholars or offer collaborative writing opportunities.

5.    Facilitating Joint Issues and Editor Networks: Journals could partner to produce joint special issues, share reviewer pools (in line with GDPR compliance), and benchmark editorial practices. A potential reviewer recognition award—possibly under the auspices of the Hall of Fame—was also discussed.

6.    Mutual Promotion of Scholarship: Journals could exchange article lists related to current or upcoming calls for papers. Authors could then cite relevant work across the ecosystem, enhancing interconnectedness and citation rates. Collective campaigns on political and moral issues in adult education could be amplified through coordinated publishing efforts.

 

Reimagining the Scholarly Commons

WG7’s vision is not just technical—it is philosophical. The group envisions a scholarly commons rooted in mutual support, knowledge sharing, and collective impact. Such unity is strategic and necessary in a field like adult and continuing education, which often receives less attention than other academic disciplines.

 

By building a shared infrastructure, journals can expand their reach and shape the public and policy discourse around lifelong learning.

 

A Forward-Looking Network of Editors and Educators

The session in Florence marked a significant step toward forming a global editorial network for adult education. Participants expressed enthusiasm about continuing the conversation through online forums, collaborative training sessions for editors, and joint research dissemination strategies.

 

The spirit of WG7 is perhaps best captured by its commitment to “coopetition”—a blend of cooperation and competition—rooted in a shared mission to elevate adult education scholarship and make it more accessible to those who need it most.

 

Update

European Lifelong Learning Magazine (ELM), a free online magazine focused on adult education and lifelong learning, has promoted the first initiative. ELM is a journalistic medium with a European scope and a global readership of around 50,000, mainly in Europe, published by the Finnish Lifelong Learning Foundation publishes it. ELM is currently seeking contributors to our column series “I argue,” which features opinion pieces written by researchers. Each column presents a focused, thought-provoking perspective on a topic in adult education or lifelong learning.